|
How To Build a Cajon - Other Links |
|
|
|
|
Written by Casey
|
|
Friday, August 14 2009 14:43 |
|
Page 10 of 12
Other Links:
- No article about musical instrument tinkering is complete without a link to the book Musical Instrument Design by Bart Hopkin. Offers all kinds of generalized information about materials, theory, ideas, etc. Though nothing in this book specifically changed the design shown here, it's a great resource, a great source of ideas (e.g. snare tensioning systems), and a must-have for home instrument DIY folks. EMI is also super-cool.
- tonecajon.com gallery - some beautiful cajon images, useful for ideas
- thomann.de is selling cajon building kits. From their website, it looks like they are available in many nations. Didn't see a US outlet -- perhaps high shipping costs would be incurred?
- A Dutch woodworker's directions on building (MS-Word files): English | Dutch
- Dale Stewart's cajon build page
- Collection of various forum messages on the subject - some general stuff, but also some measurements, specific instructions, etc.
- Older Germán Ocaña PDF (Español)
- Another older Germán Ocaña PDF: Español (PDF) | English (MS-Word)
- Picture of one non-expert person's design - see the links section for the "fancier shop" for more on this image
- "how to build a cajon" page - not so detailed, not maintained (from Google cache, lacks images)
- Trying to build a cajon - YouTube. Not super-informative, fairly redundant, and mostly about the frame, but maybe it will lead to something. A good reminder that one can use screws and glue in combination in lieu of clamps.
- Computer graphics - YouTube. Apparently from Germán Ocaña. Very similar to this design. Might help with the visualization.
- More computer graphics - YouTube. Tantalizing and short. No particular details given.
- Playful image of a person's impressions of how bass waves in their trapezoidal cajon might interact with a piezo pickup/soundboard combination inside.
- Cajon built in a much fancier shop than my basement by non-cajon-experts.
- cajondrumming.com - a young website similar in some ways to this one, but more wide-ranging.
- Cajon Fu - a VSTi plugin for digital audio
- Wikipedia page on the cajon
- Cajon Peruano - click on "Peruvian Cajon" on the right for some history of the cajon
- Plenty of cajon playing demonstrations on YouTube, and of course you can always Google for more cajon information. Lots of little discussions on woodworking and percussion sites about building them.
|
|
Last Updated on Sunday, October 17 2010 11:15 |
...with a couple amendments that I haven't updated the article with:
- now that my door is better sealed, hole size does indeed matter. Smaller = deeper resonant pitch of kick sound, as you'd expect; too small = too deep.
- i'd put it in the back, maybe lower back actually, contrary to what the article says, but upper back seems to be the collective wisdom, so maybe that's right.
As far as overall impact on the sound that hole location has, ignoring the placement of the instrument against walls and so forth, I can't say; haven't done enough experimentation. I'd be surprised if it made a big difference.
-c
I don't have any experience with Masonite, really... my impression is that there'd be a lot of internal damping and it'd be kind of floppy, so it's probably not the first thing i'd reach for, but who knows... maybe it would have a nice dull thud without non-harmonic overtones, etc. I think we need more experimentation with cajon tapas, so hey, give it a shot and report back. :-) The birch plywood i used for mine seemed awful floppy as well before it was screwed down on the frame, so maybe masonite would be ok. As long as you don't glue it, it should be easy to try a couple or even several different materials for the tapa.
Good luck,
-c
I was curious what your thoughts were on using Masonite for the tapa?
I've been promising an update to this site for a year now, but i swear to god it's coming, hopefully this winter. I did a bunch of home-spun research on the resonance issues with the kick sound / tapa / helmholtz chamber / etc and can't wait to compare notes with that PDF. I also installed a couple pickups in my cajon and will share info about that.
I mention somewhere in this article that the hole size doesn't seem to affect the kick pitch, but I think that was due to my door. More later, but suffice to say that it does, now that I've made some modifications.
Regarding your comments:
- yeah, it's amazing how much better a home-made cajon can sound than a store-bought cajon.
- snare wise, my vote is still for clipped snares (one end free) angled up in to the corners. The trouble is the mounting system, but if you sort that out it's the best separation i've found. It takes a lot of careful adjustment though, for sure. I spend probably an hour tweaking with it when i first set it up... has to lie just right with the right tension or it "slaps" as you say. My new snare uses a very thick electrical cable (gauge 10 i think... underground feeder cable for a 100 amp panel).
- in terms of two compartments... i've never played a 2-compartment cajon i liked, but i haven't played many (1 or 2). Seems like you'd be undercutting whatever vibration the kick was going to have... i.e. why not just make two drums, at that point. I've also found that playing technique can eventually help with the separation, once you get to know your cajon.
- I saw somewhere on the internet a kick pedal for cajon... it turns 180 degrees so you can play it normally and it kicks towards you. I think it was expensive. I have a regular pedal and might try modifying it some day, but not soon. :-) If someone finds that, let me know, and i'll link to it.
-c
Nice big bass and surprisingly crisp sound - like a tight heavy kit - the tapa was a very thin but dense ply I found on an old wardrobe. Easily as loud as the bought one his uncle played the day before (http://www.tocapercussion.com/product/ethnic/cajon.html)
Playing around with the with snare: Tried the curtain hanging wire (2m for $3.80 Bunnings) and very easy to strip, then stretch. Trouble is, very difficult to isolate snare from bass. Started with crosswise like http://caseyconnor.org/cajonstuff/images/johnscajon3.png but way too much snare on bass hit. Tried just on corner which was better but still not isolating very well, and more "slappy" than "buzzy". Also wondering if it would work to divide the box into 2 compartments, a lower (roughly square) box for the bass and the top would be for slap and snare. Another question - why not rig up a bass kick so we can have 2 hands free plus kick bass...
Anyway... Still experimenting...
i just change my blog name. it is now become
http://isdcajon.blogspot.com/
visit us
thank you
Blockboard is stronger than plywood and has enough density. google it, you'll have more information about it.
i make them quickly? i just can't waste my time by daydreaming:-)lol
thanks for the inspiration Casey
Blockboard - had to look that up. It worked well? Strong enough, etc?
I think maybe you have misunderstood "ocana". Germán Ocaña is a person -- a cajon builder who provided a lot of the data I used to make my cajon (see info, above.) As far as I'm aware, it's not a part of the cajon.
Glad your design is coming along.
i just build a new one. this time i don't use plywood or MDF but i take blockboard. i use it coz i think it is healthier than MDF. and the result is quite satisfying! its dimension is 11.5'x11.5'x17.5'. unlike the previous one, i can feel more bass sound. well, the thickness of the back ocana might be the thing and i put the 13cm hole right in the middle. and i add another thing here, that is ADJUSTABLE SNARE! it's a real thing man. just get into my blog to see it. thank you Casey!
saint avee
insaintdesign.blogspot.com
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UA7TdAAPIR4
thank you
saint avee-inSaint Design cajon
I don't think MDF would sound any different than plywood, and it might be harder to work with (e.g. screwing the tapa on might split it?) I don't have much experience with it. Other than that, I don't think using it would hurt anything. But I would concentrate on the size, the tapa, and the snare type/placement: that's where the sound is really decided. After that, the sound seal, the way the tapa is screwed (how many screws, how it sits on the internal frame, where the screws are), and maybe the orientation of the tapa grain (?). I have found that the hole size is almost irrelevant, and I am guessing that the material used in the sides is pretty unimportant. A comment below stated: "The choice of materials that you use will decide the tone of the cajon. The harder the wood, the more cutting the sound will be. The softer the wood the more warm it will be. You don't want to go too far either way, look for a wood that will have a nice balance. One of my favorite choices for the shell of a cajon is poplar."
I did see your blog. Very pretty. :-)
i make it smaller since in my country, indonesia, the average people height is only about 170 cm and i'm only 160 cm.
what do you think about using 12 mm MDF to replace the body?
did you see my blog already?
http://insaintdesign.blogspot.com/
i use 3 mm plywood for tapa and i don't glue it to its body, i use screw as you said.
snappy snare here is the wire that is used below the real drum snare. i cut it into two and set it inside the cajon toward the inside tapa.
while, the hole diameter is 13 cm.
What do you mean by "snappy" snare?
How thick is your tapa? Is it plywood also?
this is the stuff
http://insaintdesign.blogspot.com/
would you please help me. Thank you
Keep in mind that the layers (plies) of wood that constitute plywood are typically oriented at 90 degrees to each other, so I would guess that orienting a plywood tapa with the visible outside grain horizontally wouldn't have a big impact, but I suppose it would depend on how many layers your plywood has, what orientation they all are, etc. I put the indicator of the grain direction in the plans because it made sense to me, but there was no especially profound reason for it, to be honest. :-) It just seemed like a predominantly vertical-grain tapa (mine is 3-ply, so the outer 2 plies are vertical) would flex more along the vertical axis (meaning, the predominant "crease" in the bending tapa runs vertically), giving the tapa a longer resonant period and thus lower sound, presuming that the cajon is taller than it is wide.
With a solid wood tapa, however, I would expect a difference. My instinct still says vertical grain, and I think that's what I've seen on expert-made instruments, but maybe you could check some pics on the internet to be sure.
If you don't glue your tapa, it's pretty easy to just make a couple and experiment.
I would like to know if it is a must to have thre tapa vertical grain ?
Will this change the sound?
I posted back in March about my adjustable snare idea and the "flip-top" access door. I finally got around to building my first cajon with a whole lot of help from your site so thank you. I've got some pictures up for you and your site visitors to look at. I know I got a lot of ideas from looking at all the other pictures out there and came up with a design based on all those, so I hope someone else can benefit from my pictures. See http://bit.ly/LK64aN for pics.
The drum sounds great with a crisp snare and some good bass. I even installed a "rest bar" for the snares to rest against when they are not against the tapa so I have both a snare cajon and a non-snare cajon in one (with no rattle when it's off).
Thanks again for your help!
Justin
I will say that my impression is that you could make a tapa with a variety of different materials. Not sure which to suggest, but e.g. plexiglass or some other synthetic would probably sound the same or better (my guess, here). I just don't think using wood is necessary in a cajon -- I mean, we're using plywood here, after all, it's not like it's a matched spruce top on a guitar or something.
And I'm assuming that there's nothing breaking down in terms of the air seal for you, which may affect the bass.
There's also "aircraft grade" plywood, which may behave differently... I believe the stuff I looked at had the sheets 45 degrees from each other instead of plywood's typical 90 (so they could steam and form it, I understand?) -- maybe it would hold up better (and maybe it would just dull the same way, eventually).
Let us know what you find out!
When the Tapas are new, they sing, crisp open highs and extraordinary lows. After approx. 30 hours of play, they sound ... flat. Besides the obvious humidity problems (live in arizona so thats not a major factor) the Tapas seem to be breaking down really fast.
Any suggestions, thoughts, ideas?
Anyway, the boards are either 3" or 9" wide by 24" long by 5/16" thick and they're rough sawn.
I can run them through a planer to smooth them down a bit, then sand them smooth.
I've got a lot of Douglas Fir I can use for the frames as well.
Recently I made another rough recording in front of the workshop playing my foot hi-hat and pro rockbox combo, I'm more of a guitarist than a drummer but it sounds ok.
The recording was done with a zoom h2 field recorder with no post production/effects right on the road.... about 5 meters away.
http://www.cajon.com.au/images/soundfiles/rockboxpromodel.mp3
http://www.cajon.com.au/images/soundfiles/vibro%20darlo.mp3
This recording is really raw and unrehearsed, it me playing pro rockbox with pedal, slide guitar, blues harp and foot hi hat, the guitar is tuned in an open minor scale.
Hope you enjoy.
If anyone of you guys knows how to build one. Please be considerate to help me. Thanks
Your directions and self-critique are thoughtful and amazingly clear. Thanks for your efforts.
I have been doing some experimenting with aspects of the design as well, and I'm looking forward to updating this site in the next month or two with a lot more data on the physics/resonance issues (tapa, air chamber) and mic'ing samples that I've made over the last couple/few years. I've been threatening a site update for a year, but i swear it's coming. :-)
You could send an email to anything at caseyconnor.org and it'll get to me (as long as it's not a spammy address like sales@ or something), so feel free.
Thanks,
-c
I have been building cajon from allsorts of bits and pieces including old wooden speakers. The snare i have built using everything from bottle caps to guitar strings. I have had some success with micing up a cajon. I simply put a old mic head inside the cajon, I dont want to give the game away as it has taken me months to get a good working prototype. but if your interested i can send you an mp3 of the mic in the cajon and then details on how i did it?
cheers
andy
ps brilliant webpage, i like the phantom power checker a lot - i have one which plays a tune!
As for the door, someone else posted alternate ideas on doors to have the bottom open so that the weight of the player created the seal needed. I liked that idea, but then you would need to have a latch system. If you built the door in the top (cut the top board in halves or a 1/3 and 2/3 split, then the front half or third could be attached creating the rigidity needed while the back half or two-thirds could open as an access hatch. That way once you sit on it you create the seal.
We'll see how my first cajon turns out, and thanks in advance for all the ideas/inspiration!
If you're going to have a snare inside, though, and if you don't have some kind of fancy adjustment system you can access when it's done, then I do recommend some way of getting inside... maybe instead of glue for the back panel, a bunch of screws (like every few inches) if it comes to that (though if using plywood you'd want the frame pieces to screw in to if you're going that route, because screwing into the edge of plywood isn't the best). The door is a pain, and the next one I build may not have it, but I would always want some way of taking it apart (with the tapa still on).
-c
I love the rich tones especially when mic'd
The only change I am going to make is to add resting block , made of scrap wood and rug, for when I disengage the snares.
Thanks again
Faria
@ched - thanks!
-c
-About how much does this cost?
...hmmm, maybe around $30, if you build the one I've shown here? That's a very rough estimate. If you salvage a crate or some plywood from somewhere (or use a speaker cabinet from Goodwill, etc), make your own snares (though i don't recommend it, really), don't spend any money on finish or sandpaper, etc, then you could do it for almost nothing but the cost of screws and glue.
-Can I have two Tapa's one on the front for bass, one on the side for snares, which will be supported by frames much like the ones you use?
I think you should try it. The argument against it might be that the bass sound would suffer with less of a rigid enclosure backing it up, but it's worth a shot.
-Can I do this myself? I haven't really built like this before, (dont worry I'm an adult, as well as a general contractor, i do repairs on houses, with guidance).
Well, not knowing you personally, I can only say that generally it's one of the easiest instrument projects there are. Basically, build a box with a thin front and a hole in the back. I made the page to help people do it themselves. :-)
-how many days does this take?
I think two, minimum, since you have to wait for glue to dry a couple times. It took me maybe 4 to 6 hours each session, but i was moving slow and taking pictures and so forth.
Good luck,
-Casey
First of before my questions and what not, this web page is particularly inspiring. I, though inexperienced, have ideas for different things I could do, which I will mention.
Here are my questions...
-About how much does this cost?
-Can I have two Tapa's one on the front for bass, one on the side for snares, which will be supported by frames much like the ones you use?
-Can I do this myself? I haven't really built like this before, (dont worry I'm an adult, as well as a general contractor, i do repairs on houses, with guidance).
-how many days does this take?
Thank you for taking the time to make this website :) God bless you, I love you song btw is it on Itunes?
Or maybe what you meant is that one end of the snare is not in contact with the tapa?
Most "real"-snare setups do that: one end is off the tapa and the snare is angled toward the tapa with a little tension to press the snares against the tapa. In other words, it doesn't sit, tensioned, on the tapa like a snare on a snare drum would. The angle that it hits the tapa at and the tension with which it is held both dramatically affect the sound of the snare (as would the length of the snares, i assume), which is why i would urge you to build in some kind of adjustability into the system until you have it perfected. As long as you have a hole in the cajon you can reach a hand in there and tweak.
-c
thank you for the reply, i am still contemplating what snare system to use, for i am not going to be tweaking it.
thank you
That looks good to me. Can I use that image on this site? The only reason I wouldn't do it that way is for adjustability... especially if you don't have a door in the cajon for more access. But if you like the sound it results in, then go for it. It's a simple and effective way of getting the snares in place (though i'd probably put them slightly more towards the corners to help with kick/snare separation). Do you think that your snares are long enough? They look like they might be on the short side and thus give kind of a short "bark" of a snare, but I don't have much experience yet tweaking with real snares.
Personally I tweak so much with the snare that the next system I make will probably have a couple movable blocks with wingnuts and bolts, etc, to allow easy but stable positioning. My current "snare on a length of stiff wire" is kind of silly, obviously, from a stability standpoint, but it does allow for infinite adjustment, which is nice.
Glad the site was useful. I'm hoping to update/overhaul it in the next couple months... stay tuned.
-c
anyway, i have not made my cajon yet but was wondering, since the main problem seems to be the snare, how affective is the idea bellow??
(if you can't see it it's just half of the snare on each side, fixed there by a simple corner block on the top)
Thank you all for all the really helpful stuff, seriously :p
http://www.framedrums.net/wp-content/uploads/cajon-flamenco-snare.jpg
-c
@Christian - Thanks for asking, I should have made that clearer. Yes, the tapa screws into the frame, and the idea is that the tapa rests right against the frame. It's OK if it touches the edges of the sides of the box as well (everything flush), but the frame is there to be a surface against which the tapa attaches. I'm not sure how crucial this would be if you were using solid wood sides, but plywood isn't great at holding screws that go in through the edges (parallel to the lamination). I think that's the main reason for the frame in this case, but maybe they do it with solid-wood-sided cajons also, for some reason of bass resonance. As described in the article, the frame should be well glued to the sides, so that there is no air gap.
-Casey
Thanks
drkirkwellness@gmail.com
Look for the line that says "Here are the plans for the cajon depicted on this article, in various formats".
You will find all measurements in the plans.
best wishes for you
If you were to switch the locations of the eyes/hooks, then the hooks would be pulling the door closed, rather than pulling it to the side of the box.
It sounds like you are happy enough with what you have that there won't be a version 2, but that seemed a simple adjustment that I thought I would mention.
Now I need to go start cutting some wood... :)
Please see page 7, "snares": http://caseyconnor.org/jl/cajon?start=6
I don't think that the strings sound good, so I don't use them. Maybe in a cajon where the strings are longer, or maybe if you want a more traditional sound, they might be OK, I don't know. For me, the true snares (not strings) sound much better.
Re: the strings, Ocana says that it's a balance. They touch the tapa, there is no real space, and he even recommends trying a piece of tape in the center, if you're having trouble. But they shouldn't be too tight. You do not tighten them like guitar strings, as far as I know.
-c
Some do run wires vertically: see this link: http://caseyconnor.org/cajonstuff/cajon-munster-english.doc
(that link is on Page 10 of this article, "Other Links": http://caseyconnor.org/jl/cajon?start=9 ). Not my cup of tea, really, since it couples the bass/snare.
I don't know exactly what you mean by "placing it up vertically on the tapa". If it's still in the corners, I'd be happy, because I like to keep separate the snare and the bass sounds. If it's in the middle of the tapa, vertically, especially if you're talking about laying the entirety of the length of the snare against the tapa, then it will always be ringing, thus turning the cajon into a big, bassy, pseudo snare drum. I like the variety of sounds the cajon can make, so I put my clipped-off snares with their ends against the corners. Running wires along the face of the cajon may be the more traditional way to do it, and most "real" cajons I hear either have very short, barky snare sounds, and/or have wires that run the entire face of the cajon and always sound when you play the instrument, neither of which was my goal.
For lots of other snare images and ideas, see the "readers respond" page: http://caseyconnor.org/jl/cajon?start=10
Re: solid wood for the other surfaces: sure, see for example http://tonecajon.com/?page=available
As long as it's strong and dense and won't split, I think anything is fair game, there.
Good luck,
-c
Re: wood, see page 3, called, cleverly, "Wood and Frame": http://caseyconnor.org/jl/cajon?start=2 -- As far as species of wood are concerned, I doubt it makes much difference, since we're talking about laminate plywood here.
Re: Ocana, see the intro page, "Germán Ocaña".
Hi -
For the tapa, see page 3, called, cleverly, "wood and frame": http://caseyconnor.org/jl/cajon?start=2
For the snares, see page 7, called, cleverly, "snares": http://caseyconnor.org/jl/cajon?start=6
Good luck,
-Casey
@Job - see http://caseyconnor.org/jl/cajon?start=3 for info about the hole size issues. The size doesn't seem to matter so much, in my experience. The function of the hole is to "let the bass out", in a simple sense; the cajon "kick" sound is making a "thud" wavefront. Without the hole, the thud hangs out inside the box and doesn't come across as loudly. My personal conviction (as explained at that link) is that the hole isn't part of a "Helmholtz" model, where it "tunes" an air spring, so much as it just prevents the air pressure of the internal space from preventing the tapa from moving and allows the thud wavefront to escape. If the tapa vibrated like a traditional drum head membrane, then the hole might be relevant, as when playing a djembe you can insert or remove a fist in the hole to change the pitch of the drum.
Gluing/nailing: see http://caseyconnor.org/jl/cajon?start=4 -- nailing or screwing into the edge of standard laminate plywood doesn't really work, so you basically need to glue. Ocana also recommends this for the sake of a good air seal via the glue. The exception, sometimes, is the tapa, which you screw into the frame (the frame is in turn glued to the inside of the plywood). Some people also glue the tapa, but i prefer to leave mine removable.
@Richard - Yeah, generally the back panel is the same as the sides, with 12mm or thicker plywood (glued all around). It's important that the cajon be sturdy/rigid. Regarding the snares, see http://caseyconnor.org/jl/cajon?start=6 ... I agree that the string-snares are not satisfying. There are a number of other ideas on that page, as well as links.
Glad the site is helpful,
-Casey
My original design borrowed your first snare idea, but across one corner only thinking that I could have a 'slap + snare' corner plus a 'slap only' corner. The snares were not very successful: if given a lot of tension they produced a distracting sort of hum. Now I have them slack and with a few loose wires wrapped around which is OK played lightly but I am working on alternatives and will post here if I have a breakthrough.
I did find that there was a nasty resonance from the back panel even though it was well screwed on, and cured that by using frameseal (the stuff that goes around window frames) applied from the inside (with the Tapa removed). I also glued a chunk of MDF to the inside of the back panel to deaden it. The bass seemed more solid after that.
Just for fun, we put an ordinary cheap PC mic inside it and played it through a computer sound card: if you want to hear that, and see the cajon, go to youtube.com/expertanswers.
Even without a microphone I am amazed at the range of sounds and dynamics you can extract from what is just a box.
Thanks
-----------------
I am thinking about building my own canjon and your experience will be very helpful I think! Can't you create a blog or something like that and share your experience? I'm sure there is many people that will appreciate!
-----------------
Yeah same here!
-----------------
-Casey
Like i said am not a pro or anything else but love the sound of this instrument.
The one i built is 18 inches tall by 12 inches wide. i did not install any type of resonating devices in it, just pure sound from what the tapa (face) would make.
I use it for the first time today at church, like i said am not a pro, but i got good results.
Thank you for all the vital information you have share with everybody else.
Thanks